“Have you accepted Jesus Christ as your personal Savior?”
What’s a personalist to make of this question?
It’s a familiar one to evangelicals—so familiar that you can easily gloss over what exactly it might mean. It’s also a question to which, since becoming a Catholic, I’ve learned a couple of preliminary comebacks:
First, of course, nowhere in the Bible does Christ say “Go out to all the nations and instruct them to accept me as their personal Savior.” It’s a relatively recent phrase, and its centrality to salvation—especially the way it displaces baptism—
is a modern invention.
Secondly, yes: the personal assent of the will, the free receptivity to the proffered gift, is indispensable. But there’s a problem with the way “personal” is used here—as synonymous with “individual”: it disregards the corporate aspect of the whole thing.
He is our personal savior, knows us by name, and doesn’t relate to us en masse—but He also saves us by incorporating us into His Mystical Body, the Church. Salvation is not an individualistic pursuit, not even for hermits..
Another possible interpretation of a “personal savior” is a savior with whom you have a comfortable, feelings-based relationship—that your religion is more than an impersonal, institutional bundle of rules, regulations, and rituals. Taken to extremes, this results in a make-it-up-as-you-go-along kind of faith.
Still, there’s a large grain of truth here that no personalist ought to overlook—Jesus Christ is a person. And what does that mean? It should give us pause no matter which denomination we call home.
But it’s awfully easy to stall right there, oblivious to how one-sided and self-centered we’re being To awaken to the idea that He’s concerned for me and sees me as a person is key, but it’s only the first half of acknowledging Him as a Person. The second half is being concerned for Him, and seeing Him as somebody with an interior, with His own subjectivity, some reality beyond the aid, consolation, and trustworthiness He offers me.
That might seem nonsensical. How can anyone be concerned for Omnipotence? Can I be anxious about God’s wellbeing, as if He were a husband driving home on a snowy night
or a teenager fallen in with a bad crowd?
He has no need of anything. That’s Theology 101. What sense does it make to be considerate of God, take His feelings into account, do Him favors, or prepare Him a special treat? This is how we show love for fellow creatures. But it doesn’t seem to fit with God.
Yet we know that love demands reciprocity. In fact, as Bl. John Paul II put it, “this reciprocity is the very foundation, the soul of the Christian life.” It’s just as vital to acknowledge the subjectivity of the other when the other is God as it is when it’s anybody else. This reciprocity, or mutuality, isn’t exhausted by determining what the commandments are and responding correctly. He is a person, with a heart capable of joy and sorrow, at the mercy—but only because He so chooses—of our response.
For more serious treatment of this mystery, see Bl. John Paul’s Salvifici doloris, St. Thérèse, St. Faustina, and all kinds of writings on the Sacred Heart. It’s not a new idea, but if we ever put it into practice it would turn everything upside down.
“Ordinarily,” observes Javier Echevarría, “we regard God as the source and content of our peace—which is true, but not the whole truth. We don’t tend to think, for example, that we too can console God and offer him a resting place. But this is how the saints have acted.”
But there’s another perspective: that of the Father.
Neither son seems mindful of his point of view—any more than we usually are of God's. Here’s Esparza, quoting Nouwen:
The elder brother…has failed to understand the love that drives his father’s continual concern for the wellbeing of both his sons—while each of them goes his own way, oblivious to the sorrow or joy he might be causing. The parable reveals not only the homeward path the prodigal son ought to take, but also the enormous pain his waywardness causes his father….“He is a God who rejoices at our affection and is pained by our coldness.” (emphasis mine)
So have you accepted Jesus Christ as your personal Savior?
And if so, are you sure you know what you’re getting into?